The Air Force’s banned briefing on the ethics of nuclear war

Who Would Jesus Nuke? The Air Force’s banned briefing on the ethics of nuclear war
https://www.muckrock.com/news/archives/2016/aug/17/who-would-jesus-nuke-wwjn-air-force-chaplains-bann/For decades, the Vandenberg Air Force base in California gave a briefing to new missile officers on the ethics of nuclear war. Then, in 2011, the watchdog group the Military Religious Freedom Foundation (MRFF) successfully lobbied to get the program suspended. If you’re wondering what was so objectionable about an ethics lesson, the fact it was more commonly referred to as the “Jesus Loves Nukes speech” might give you a hint.

 

Following the controversy, MuckRock’s Michael Morisy requested a copy of the presentation from the Air Force, which it promptly released. Let’s take a look.

 

After a cover slide that just says “ETHICS” in size 72 font, the briefing starts off with a list of the five core ethical principals for service to the Air Force. Even without the associated lesson plan, some slides are fairly self explanatory …

worlds.jpg

while others are, well, less so.

acar.jpg

With those out of the way, the presentation then turns to the main event …

nenw.jpg

which it breaks down into four sub-categories.

overview.jpg

Not much time is spent on the first, which basically boils down to “Turns out, there’s more to the military than just solid pay and great healthcare.”

doyoubelieve.jpg

Having established that you’re not just here for the pension, the slides then go on to tackle the question “Can a Person of Faith fight in a War?” By way of answer, examples are offered of people of faith who demonstrably did fight in war, such as Joshua Chamberlain, George Washington, “Stonewall” Jackson …

offaith.jpg

and of course, Mel Gibson.

warandfaith.jpg

Alright, so now we know that it can be done, next up is the big one: should it be done?

canwarbejust.jpg

Their answer, which will come as no surprise to Classics majors or people who attended Catholic school, involves this guy:

augustine.jpg

And, spoiler alert, the answer is “pretty much, yeah.”

prettymuchyeah.jpg

The presentation then goes on to include a diverse and inclusive list of examples of just war, ranging all the way from the Old Testament …

ot2.jpg

…including this rather odd aside about Judaism never having a “pacifistic sentiment”…

maccabees.jpg

to the New Testament …

centurion.jpg

skipping right past the “live by the sword, die by the sword” and “turn the other cheek” Jesus to the cool warrior Jesus at the end.

1911.jpg

Tying it all together, we turn to the specific moral quandary of the nuclear officer of faith in a just war …

nuclearofficer.jpg

which draws from a rather obvious example.

hiroshima.jpg

Though terrible, the presentation argues, the Hiroshima bombing actually saved lives in the long run, and, hey, they would have nuked us first.

however.jpg

Finally, the question: could you turn the key?

thequestion.jpg

Bonus follow-up question: really, are you any less morally culpable if you don’t turn the key? Somebody else will just turn the key!

morallysafer.jpg

To wrap things up, the presentation appeals to no less a moral authority than an actual Nazi.

nazi.jpg

To be fair, the guy was an authority on blowing things up without losing any sleep over it.

Read the presentation embedded below or on the request page.




Translate »